Why it matters
Google would pay the yearly cost of Xcel's new power plants for 15 years from each one's start, on a separate bill line, with credits for their power and capacity. Xcel says other customers would gain $1.1 billion, while the Attorney General's office puts the figure nearer $1 billion of costs. The cost model is sealed and the Commission has yet to rule.
Tap a figure for the line in its source.
Xcel Energy gives Google
- of electric service at 345 kV for the Pine Island data center, for 15 years from the later of the Commission's approval and the day Xcel's facilities can be energized — from 2028 by Xcel's plan; the contract capacity and its ramp are redacted, 780 being the size Google let Xcel disclose in Oct 2026
- monthly credits on its bill for the energy and capacity the portfolio provides — at retail rates for what matches its own use, at market prices for the excess — while the plants serve all Xcel's customers and their renewable energy credits stay with Xcel
Google gives Xcel Energy
- disputedminimum bill: demand charges on 75% of the contracted capacity whatever it uses, as the contract was filed, plus the customer charge, riders and the clean-energy charge — but 80% under the large-customer tariff the Commission approved in June 2026, after the contract was filed; which floor governs Google's contract is undecided
- Clean Energy Accelerator Charge: a fixed monthly charge for the full yearly revenue requirement — capital, depreciation, Xcel's return, operating costs and taxes, less tax credits — of 1,400 of wind, 200 MW of solar and 300 MW of 100-hour Form Energy iron-air batteries, for 15 years from each one's start, even past the contract's end; costs above today's estimates only up to a redacted margin
- toward Capacity*Connect, Xcel's program of small batteries at customer sites in Minnesota, after its load ramp starts
- the estimated cost of the wires to the campus, all paid by Google — $78–88M of it (our sum) for a 1.2-mile, 345 kV line and work at the North Rochester substation that Xcel owns, the rest for four campus substations that Google builds and owns
- notice if it leaves early, with an exit fee — as filed, 75% of on-peak demand charges for the rest of the term or 96 months, whichever is shorter, plus the remaining clean-energy charges (80% for the whole remainder under the tariff); backed by a guaranty, cash or a letter of credit worth three months of minimum bills
What happened
Xcel Energy's Minnesota utility signed a contract in January 2026 to power a planned Google data center at Pine Island, south of the Twin Cities. Google let Xcel disclose the data center's 780 megawatts in October. Google would pay large-customer rates, with a minimum bill regardless of use. A new charge would cover the yearly cost of 1,900 megawatts of wind, solar and 100-hour iron-air batteries. Xcel would own and run those resources for all its customers. Google would get bill credits for the power and capacity they provide. Xcel says Google pays all its costs and other customers come out about $1.1 billion ahead over 15 years. The state Attorney General's office says those customers may be about $1 billion worse off. It says they could be left paying for the new plants if Google cuts back or leaves. Minnesota's regulators expect to decide in early 2027.
Sources 25 documents — 7 other documents · 5 regulatory filings · 5 SEC filings · 4 press reports · 2 company releases · 2 government statements
Research trail Found 64 documents and read 63 of them while checking this deal and related ones.
- States 7 figures: parties · term · 75% minimum bill · ceac charge · 300 MW storage · $50M capacity connect · termination
- States 3 figures: approval · 1,900 MW ceac portfolio · 1,000 MW ceac approvals
- States announced
- States 780 MW load
- States $198–248M transmission
- Cited by the record; no single figure is quoted from it.
- Cited by the record; no single figure is quoted from it.
- Cited by the record; no single figure is quoted from it.
- Cited by the record; no single figure is quoted from it.
- Cited by the record; no single figure is quoted from it.
- Cited by the record; no single figure is quoted from it.
- Cited by the record; no single figure is quoted from it.
- Cited by the record; no single figure is quoted from it.
- Cited by the record; no single figure is quoted from it.
- Cited by the record; no single figure is quoted from it.
- Cited by the record; no single figure is quoted from it.
- Cited by the record; no single figure is quoted from it.
- Cited by the record; no single figure is quoted from it.
- Cited by the record; no single figure is quoted from it.
- Cited by the record; no single figure is quoted from it.
- Cited by the record; no single figure is quoted from it.
- Cited by the record; no single figure is quoted from it.
- Cited by the record; no single figure is quoted from it.
- Cited by the record; no single figure is quoted from it.
- Cited by the record; no single figure is quoted from it.
The record's own summary of its sourcing: Minnesota PUC Docket E002/M-26-170 — Xcel's petition with the ESA, the Interconnection Agreement and Attachments C-1 and E (Apr 14 2026), its Sep 28 2026 delay-scenario letter, its Oct 9 2026 response to Xcel Large Industrials' motion, Google's initial comments (Sep 28 2026) and the staff briefing papers for Oct 22 2026; the Commission's order in Docket E002/M-25-289 (Jun 12 2026); Xcel Energy and NSP-Minnesota 10-Qs for Q1–Q3 2026 and the Q3 release (8-K, furnished Oct 29 2026); the Applicants' proposed findings in the route-permit docket (Oct 2 2026); Xcel's and Google's announcements (Feb 24 2026); the Attorney General's office release (Oct 1 2026), CUB, CNBC, Utility Dive, Canary Media, MCEA, Cliff and MPR News for the contested cells (read 2026-11) · as of Nov 2026
The evidence 13 sourced figures · 7 disputes
The record's headline Xcel–Google: power for a 780 Google data center at Pine Island, Minnesota for 15 years, with a minimum bill and a Clean Energy Accelerator Charge through which Google pays the yearly cost of 1,900 MW of wind, solar and Form Energy iron-air storage that Xcel would own for all its customers — before the Minnesota PUC, decision expected early 2027, with the Attorney General's office disputing Xcel's ~$1.1B of benefits to other customers
- Size
- 15-year electric service agreement (from the later of approval and energization; service from 2028 by Xcel's plan) · 780 MW · minimum bill on 75% of demand charges as filed (80% under the Jun 2026 tariff order — contested) · Clean Energy Accelerator Charge for 1,900 MW: 1,400 MW of wind, 200 MW of solar, 300 MW / 30 GWh of Form Energy iron-air storage, each asset's revenue requirement for 15 years from its start · $50M to Capacity*Connect · $198–248M of transmission and substations, paid by Google
- When
- Jan 30 2026 (ESA dated) → Feb 24 2026 (announced by Xcel and Google) → Apr 14 2026 (petition dated; posted Apr 15) → Apr 30 2026 (Xcel's Q1 10-Q) → May 22 2026 (court rules for MCEA; campus construction halted) → Jun 5 and Jul 1 2026 (two sealed amendments) → Jun 12 2026 (tariff order: the very large customer class, 80% floors) → Sep 28 2026 (initial comments; Xcel's 15-month-delay scenario) → Oct 1 2026 (Attorney General's release on its comments) → Oct 9 2026 (780 MW disclosed) → Oct 22 2026 (Commission agenda: XLI's motion) → Oct 28 2026 (MCEA suit settled) → Oct 29 2026 (Q3 10-Q: 1,000 MW approved, decision expected early 2027) → Nov 16 2026 (response comments due) → early 2027 (decision expected) → 2028 (service, by Xcel's plan) → Dec 2029 (line in service, by the route docket)
- Status
- pending before the Minnesota PUC: petition dated Apr 14 2026 (posted Apr 15), decision asked for by Q4 2026 and now 'expected in early 2027' (Xcel's Q3 10-Q); initial comments Sep 28, reply comments Oct 21 and response comments Nov 16 2026. Xcel Large Industrials' Sep 25 motion for a contested case and to lift the 'Highly Confidential' designations was on the Commission's Oct 22 agenda — no outcome in the documents read — and Xcel undertook to re-file the petition with fewer redactions by Oct 16 (not on file). Of the 1,900 MW, 1,000 MW of resources approved in Xcel's other procurement dockets by Q3 2026, the rest to be requested by Q2 2027. The campus: construction halted by a court order in May 2026 in MCEA's suit against the city's environmental review, settled Oct 28 2026 with a state-led review, the project not to be built until the city and the state agency approve a mitigation plan
- Structure
- an Electric Service Agreement dated Jan 30 2026 between Northern States Power Company (NSP-Minnesota, doing business as Xcel Energy) and Echo Zone, LLC, a subsidiary of Google LLC ('Google' in the filings), with an Interconnection Agreement for retail service at transmission voltage that runs 20 years from Google's notice to construct — both before the Minnesota PUC in Docket E002/M-26-170 (the sealed versions in E002/M-26-171), with two amendments of Jun 5 and Jul 1 2026 filed under seal in their entirety. The Clean Energy Accelerator Charge (the ESA's Exhibit C) assigns Google the costs of resources that Xcel owns or controls and dispatches for its whole system; their environmental attributes, renewable energy credits included, stay with Xcel. The 345 kV line and the North Rochester substation work are Xcel's, the four campus substations Google's, under a route permit sought in a companion docket. The campus, Project Skyway, is Ryan Companies' development, Google its first tenant
- Programme
- Time-to-power
- Parties
- Google customer — Echo Zone, LLC, a subsidiary of Google LLC, which takes the power for its Pine Island data center, pays the Clean Energy Accelerator Charge for the 1,900 MW portfolio and the cost of the transmission, and builds and owns the campus's four substations · Xcel Energy utility — Northern States Power Company (NSP-Minnesota), which serves the load, owns or controls and dispatches the portfolio for all its customers and keeps its renewable energy credits, credits Google for the portfolio's energy and capacity, and builds and owns the 345 kV line and the North Rochester substation work
- Record
- disclosed / primary source · as of Nov 2026
Flows 2 as the record states them
- Xcel Energy → Googlepowerelectric service at 345 kV to the Pine Island data center for 15 years from the later of approval and energization (from 2028 by Xcel's plan), up to a contract capacity the filing redacts — 780 MW, as Google let Xcel disclose in Oct 2026 — served from Xcel's system, with the portfolio's matched energy and capacity credited on Google's bill; the portfolio's renewable energy credits stay Xcel's
- Google → Xcel Energypower-paymentsbase rates, fuel and riders under the large-customer tariff, with a minimum monthly bill of 75% of demand charges on the contracted capacity as filed (80% under the tariff order — contested); the Clean Energy Accelerator Charge, a fixed monthly charge recovering the 1,900 MW portfolio's full annual revenue requirement, Xcel's return included, for 15 years from each asset's start, less monthly energy and capacity credits; $50M to Capacity*Connect after its load ramp starts; the transmission's construction cost ($198–248M with Google's own substations); an exit fee if it leaves early
Resolved figures 13 each with the verbatim line from its document
- announcedfirst public on Feb 24 2026, when Xcel announced it 'will power a new Google data center in Pine Island, Minnesota' and Google's blog announced the data center the same day: 'With Xcel Energy supplying energy for the new data center, Google will pay all costs associated with our electric service.' Until then the campus was Ryan Companies' Project Skyway, its tenant unnamed — the developer 'later announced that Google was the company behind the data center' (MCEA). The release said the ESA 'will be filed for review with the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission in the coming weeks'; it first appears in an SEC filing in Xcel's Q1 10-Q (Apr 30 2026), which dates its signing to the first quarter
“MINNEAPOLIS (Feb. 24, 2026) — Xcel Energy (NASDAQ: XEL) announced today it will power a new Google data center in Pine Island, Minnesota.”
Xcel Energy release (Feb 24 2026) · newsroom.xcelenergy.com - partiesan Electric Service Agreement 'made and entered into as of the 30th day of January, 2026' between Northern States Power Company (NSP-Minnesota) and Echo Zone, LLC, 'a subsidiary of Google LLC (hereinafter, Google)', with an Interconnection Agreement for retail service at transmission voltage whose term 'is for 20 years and commences upon the customer providing their Notice to Construct to the Company'. The public copy redacts the contract capacity, the ramp, the extension period, the CEAC's target revenue requirement and its cost margins; two later amendments (Jun 5 and Jul 1 2026), each a 'newly executed provision agreed to by the parties', are sealed in their entirety. At Google's request the ESA says 'Where there is any conflict between this Agreement and the Tariff, the terms of the Agreement will control' (minimum-bill-floor). Xcel's Q3 10-Q: 'In the first quarter of 2026, NSP-Minnesota entered into an ESA to power a new Google data center in Minnesota.'
“THIS ELECTRIC SERVICE AGREEMENT (“Agreement”) is made and entered into as of the 30th day of January, 2026, by and between Northern States Power Company, an Xcel Energy company and a Minnesota corporation, doing business as Xcel Energy”
Xcel petition to the Minnesota PUC, Docket E002/M-26-170, Attachment A (the ESA) (Apr 14 2026) · minnesotapuc.legistar.com - approvalpending. The petition (dated Apr 14 2026, posted Apr 15 by the staff briefing papers' list) asked for 'a decision from the Commission by the fourth quarter of 2026'; Xcel's Q3 10-Q (Oct 29 2026), like its Q2 one, expects it 'in early 2027', and its Oct 9 response says the case 'is on track for resolution by the first quarter of 2027'. Xcel Large Industrials asked on Sep 25 for a contested case — which, Xcel answered, 'would effectively re-start the proceeding' — and to strip the 'Highly Confidential Trade Secret' labels; the motion was on the Commission's Oct 22 agenda with no final action recorded on file. The large-customer tariff itself was approved earlier, by the order of Jun 12 2026 (minimum-bill-floor)
“A decision is expected in early 2027.”
Xcel Energy 10-Q for Q3 2026 (Oct 29 2026) · sec.gov - load780 MW780 MW — the size of the ESA, kept a trade secret until Xcel's Oct 9 2026 response, which says Google agreed to share it 'in response to stakeholder feedback and based on the stage in the project development cycle'. Neither the 10-Q nor the release states a load. Exhibit E's contract capacity, maximum contract capacity and ramp stay redacted, and how the 780 MW maps onto the campus — 'one initial data center building and supporting infrastructure' committed, 'plans for up to three additional data center buildings' (the Applicants' proposed findings, Oct 2 2026) — no document says. Earlier and other figures for the campus's size are contested (campus-size)
“In addition, in response to stakeholder feedback and based on the stage in the project development cycle, Google has determined that it is able to share that the proposed ESA is for 780 megawatts.”
Xcel response to Xcel Large Industrials' motion, Docket E-002/M-26-170 (Oct 9 2026) · minnesotapuc.legistar.com - term1515 years: the ESA 'shall remain in full force and effect for fifteen (15) years following the Effective Date' — the later of the Commission's final approval and the day Xcel's facilities can be energized, 'but in no event earlier than the Load Ramp Start Date' (§§ 10.1–10.2) — then extends itself for a redacted period unless terminated. The petition expects Google to begin service in 2028. The tariff order later set an ESA term of 'at least 15 years' for the class
“This ESA term is 15 years.”
Xcel petition, Docket E002/M-26-170 (Apr 14 2026) · minnesotapuc.legistar.com - minimum-bill75%as filed: 'the greater of actual on-peak monthly demand charges or 75 percent of demand charges calculated based on Google’s contracted capacity', plus the customer charge, riders on actual use and the full Clean Energy Accelerator Charge, 'including during the load ramp period'. Google takes service on the Large General Time of Day tariff then pending, whose design recovers more through demand charges: the petition's sample bill at transmission voltage, for a 100 MW customer at a 90% load factor, puts its demand charges at $22.84 per kW-month against $10.08 under the current A15 rate, for the same total of $40,037,265 a year (Attachment E) — a design illustration, not Google's bill. The Commission's Jun 12 2026 order then set the class's minimum bill at 80% of contract capacity; which floor governs Google's contract is contested (minimum-bill-floor)
“Google is required to pay a Minimum Monthly Bill of the greater of actual on-peak monthly demand charges or 75 percent of demand charges calculated based on Google’s contracted capacity.”
Xcel petition, Docket E002/M-26-170 (Apr 14 2026) · minnesotapuc.legistar.com - ceac-chargethe Clean Energy Accelerator Charge (CEAC), which 'financially assigns to Google the costs of a defined portfolio of clean energy and system assets and provides capacity and energy credits from the portfolio to Google' — 'the same structure as the Clean Transition Tariff (CTT) Google developed with NV Energy' (Google's blog). Google pays each asset's full annual revenue requirement, Xcel's return included, as 'a fixed monthly charge added to Google’s bill', levelized per asset, for 'fifteen (15) years following its respective Asset Commercial Operation Date' — so payments for an asset that starts late in the ESA run past it: 'Google will be responsible for full payment of the 15-year CEAC revenue requirement for each asset, notwithstanding the remaining term of the ESA'. Costs above current expectations are Google's only up to a redacted margin. Against it Google is credited each month for the portfolio's energy that matches its hourly use (at the fuel clause plus the tariff's energy rates) and its accredited capacity up to Google's demand (at the production part of the demand charge), and for any excess at MISO prices — energy at the nodal price, capacity at the Zone 1 auction price; it also pays a monthly administration fee (redacted). The portfolio 'will not cover Google’s total capacity and energy needs, nor are they intended to' (the rest comes from Xcel's ordinary planning, at tariff rates); the resources are 'system assets like any other resource owned or controlled by the Company'; and 'All environmental attributes, including RECs, will belong to the Company', Google getting a yearly attestation letter. The CEAC's target revenue requirement and the monthly charge are redacted
“For the duration of the CEAC, Google will pay the full annual revenue requirements for the proposed clean energy portfolio, including all actual capital costs, annual depreciation expense and return on the Company’s investment for the CEAC assets, annual operating expenses, annual tax expenses, and any annual tax credits.”
Xcel petition, Docket E002/M-26-170 (Apr 14 2026) · minnesotapuc.legistar.com - ceac-portfolio1,900 MW1,900 MW: 1,400 MW of wind, 200 MW of solar and 300 MW of long-duration storage, Xcel-owned or -controlled. Attachment C-1 names the assets with target CODs: Sherco 4 solar, 200 MW (Oct 1 2029); Apex Boxcar Phases 3 and 4 wind, 269.8 and 201.4 MW (Dec 1 2029); Bedrock Little Rock wind, 300.2 MW (Dec 1 2030); Form Energy storage in three 100 MW phases (Dec 31 2029, 2030 and 2031); and '[TBD] Wind' of 628.6 MW with no date, not yet 'Requested to be Assigned to Portfolio' — a third of the total unidentified. As a ratepayer protection 'the average cost of CEAC Assets will not be less than the average cost of other similar resources procured by the Company of the same generation type'. Approvals for 1,000 MW were 'pending' in the Q1 and Q2 10-Qs and 'have been received as part of existing resource acquisition processes' in the Q3 one, which expects the rest to be requested 'by the second quarter of 2027' (by 'the end of 2026' in the Q2 10-Q). The named wind comes through a procurement docket opened in 2023 — 23-342, 'Xcel Wind Development Transfer RFP', where Xcel asked approval for 1,269 MW in Little Rock (300 MW) and the whole of Box Car (969 MW, of which C-1 holds phases 3 and 4), 'part of a broader clean energy portfolio for Google' (the PUC's May 2026 bulletin); whether the portfolio adds to what Xcel would have built no document says. When it comes online is contested (portfolio-online)
“A request for approval of the ESA, including a proposed Clean Energy Accelerator Charge for 1,900 MW of clean energy resources, was filed with the MPUC in April 2026.”
Xcel Energy 10-Q for Q3 2026 (Oct 29 2026) · sec.gov - ceac-approvals1,000 MW1,000 MW of the 1,900 MW approved by Q3 2026 in Xcel's other resource dockets, not in this one — 'pending' in the Q1 and Q2 10-Qs; the remaining resources 'are expected to be requested in those processes by the second quarter of 2027'. The 10-Q does not say which resources
“Approvals for 1,000 MW of resources for the Clean Energy Accelerator program have been received as part of existing resource acquisition processes.”
Xcel Energy 10-Q for Q3 2026 (Oct 29 2026) · sec.gov - storage300 MW300 MW of Form Energy iron-air batteries discharging for 100 hours — 30 GWh, in three 100 MW phases (ceac-portfolio). 'Without the financial support provided by the CEAC, the Company’s investment in this technology would not be cost effective to add to our system under standard resource planning' (the petition), which expects the 300 MW to offset 'approximately 120 MW of generic CT capacity needs', from an IRP ratio of about 2.5 to 1. 'The largest battery project by gigawatt-hour energy capacity announced to date in the world' is the parties' and Form's own description; no third-party ranking is on file. Form's first 100-hour system, a 1.5 MW pilot for Great River Energy in Minnesota, was reported on the grid by Latitude Media and still finishing installation by Canary Media, a day apart in Feb 2026
“An important element of the CEAC Portfolio is that it includes 300 MW of 100-hour duration iron air batteries – an innovative clean, firm technology that is the largest scale deployment of this technology announced world-wide.”
Xcel petition, Docket E002/M-26-170 (Apr 14 2026) · minnesotapuc.legistar.com - capacity-connect$50M$50M from Google toward Capacity*Connect, Xcel's program of 1–3 MW batteries at customer sites in Minnesota ('Customer agrees to provide $50,000,000 funding to support Company’s Capacity*Connect program', ESA § C.9.1), paid after Google's load ramp starts. It complements a Phase 2 program of up to 200 MW and $430M the Commission approved on Apr 2 2026 — the $430M is the program's budget, not Google's money; how many MW Google's $50M buys is redacted
“In addition to the CEAC assets described above, the portfolio also includes a $50 million contribution by Google after their load ramp start date, to support the development of Capacity*Connect.”
Xcel petition, Docket E002/M-26-170 (Apr 14 2026) · minnesotapuc.legistar.com - transmission$198–248M$198M–$248M for the North Rochester to Skyway project, all paid by Google ('The construction costs for the Project will be paid for by Google'): the 1.2-mile, double-circuit 345 kV line ($8–10M), changes to Xcel's existing North Rochester substation ($12–16M) and its expansion ($58–62M), all Xcel's to own and run ($78–88M together, our sum), and four Project Skyway substations ($120–160M) that 'Google will construct, own, and operate'. The Applicants' estimate, restated in the briefing papers and their proposed findings; construction from May 2027 for about 2.5 years. When the line is in service is contested (line-in-service). Initial service needs one of the two 345 kV circuits
“Estimated costs to construct the Project are anticipated to be between $198 million and $248 million.”
Applicants' response and proposed findings, route permit docket (Oct 2 2026) · legalectric.org - terminationat least 24Google may leave for its convenience on at least 24 months' notice, paying an Exit Fee: 'multiplying on-peak demand charges by 75 percent for the lesser of the remaining term or 96 months, as well as any remaining CEACs' — eight years at most of the demand-charge part, and every remaining clean-energy charge (minimum-bill-floor sets it against the tariff's). The parties are to mitigate, the mitigation payment capped at the Exit Fee, which first offsets the CEAC tracker balance. Security: 'a required guaranty for the ESA term, cash, or a letter of credit in an amount equal to three (3) months of Minimum Monthly Bill', and more if a credit event hits — among the triggers, neither Google nor its guarantor rated and the guarantor's cash balance 'less than three billion dollars ($3,000,000,000)'. If the Commission rejects or changes the contract and the parties cannot agree on amendments within 120 days, either may terminate
“The Google ESA may be terminated in various ways: by mutual agreement, with at least 24-months’ notice prior to the date of termination for customer’s convenience, or upon uncured breach by the either party.”
Xcel petition, Docket E002/M-26-170 (Apr 14 2026) · minnesotapuc.legistar.com
Contested figures 17 not reconciled — every position side by side, with its source and tier
Scope note what this record leaves to other records
Not this record: Minnesota Power's contract with Google (Harmony Group LLC) for a data center at Hermantown — its own petition (ESA_20263-229694-01.pdf, despite the name), 700 MW of wind and lithium-ion storage, an 80% minimum bill and $600–800M of benefits by Minnesota Power's estimate; its 15 years, 80%, $5M, 300 MW and 400 MW collide with Pine Island's and are not carried here; AES's 20-year agreement with Google in Texas (an aside in the Reuters item); the campus itself — Ryan Companies' Project Skyway, about 482 acres (480 in the petition), Google's 88-acre site, a building of 250,000, 300,000 or 2,850,000 square feet depending on the source (unresolved), the city's tax model (~$167.5M of new taxes, a ~$36.5M abatement, ~$131M net over 28 years, on an eight-year, 11-building build-out), the Panther Program for the schools ($24M, ~$24.2M or $25M), the $3.29M Community Betterment Fund, about 100 permanent jobs, Deloitte's ~3,400 construction-period jobs for Google, the $4M performance bond, Google's 'expected to exceed $700 million' for the initial phase and 'over $250 million' of community contributions, and the $5M a year fee the statute sets for loads of 750 MW or more; MCEA's suit (injunction May 2026 on a $2,000 bond; settled Oct 28 2026 — 90 days of public comment); the Department of Commerce's $250,000 request for technical help; Form Energy's own finances ($750M Series G, Aug 2026, no Google entity among the investors named; ~80 GWh backlog; a 500 MW-a-year factory target for 2028); Xcel's company-wide plans (on the xcel entity). Not adopted: the 'up to $1.5 billion' of savings — a 24/7 Wall St headline on a Yahoo recommendation card and Cliff's page, the article itself not on file, no Xcel, PUC or SEC document stating it; Cliff's 750 MW under a 'Primary source' label (campus-size); Utility Dive's 'nearly 1 GW' read as 1 GW; the Attorney General's net cost and Xcel's net benefit both read as a bare $1B, the sign only in the sentence; Attachment E's $40,037,265 bill and 100 MW load, a rate-design sample, not Google's; the city page's 'February 24, 2025' and 'December 16th, 2026', each contradicted on the same page; the Hermantown filing's '$41,976.922' for $41,976,922.